This is a perfect example of why listening to one irritated contractor does not make a companies policy...
Nope, one irritated contractor does not make policy, nor should they. It is a real shame that policy, once set, is not enforced equally. Not that anyone who has been around would expect that. Life is not fair and neither are corporations. They are what they are and I have never seen a bit of difference in any of them. One just deals with what they pass out. Say your piece, then do what you need for you personal business plan.