Phil Robertson - Duck Dynasty

letzrockexpress

Veteran Expediter
I don't know. Was his remarks, who ever he is, directed at an individual? Phil's remarks, whether you like them or not, were based on his beliefs about groups, not individuals. They are based, rightly or wrongly, on religious beliefs. What were this Bashir dudes remarks based on? What did he say?

Was it directed at an individual? Seriously? Did you read the question?
 

letzrockexpress

Veteran Expediter
In any event, GQ is known as kind of a Metro Sexual magazine. Ol' Phil should have been well aware of what he was getting into...
 

witness23

Veteran Expediter
I don't know. Was his remarks, who ever he is, directed at an individual? Phil's remarks, whether you like them or not, were based on his beliefs about groups, not individuals. They are based, rightly or wrongly, on religious beliefs. What were this Bashir dudes remarks based on? What did he say?

First question: Why does it matter if any remarks are made to an individual or group?

Second question: Why wouldn't you look up the "Bashir Dude's" remarks then comment on Letzrocks' post?

Seriously man, it's as if your trying to hard not know what he's talking about but you actually do know more than you are letting on. The lady doth protest too much, if you will.
 

layoutshooter

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
First question: Why does it matter if any remarks are made to an individual or group?

Second question: Why wouldn't you look up the "Bashir Dude's" remarks then comment on Letzrocks' post?

Seriously man, it's as if your trying to hard not know what he's talking about but you actually do know more than you are letting on. The lady doth protest too much, if you will.

I WAS trying to have a conversation with Rocket. I wanted to know HIS thoughts. Not yours.
 

Brisco

Expert Expediter
The Majority of Americans don't even know who either one of them are.

OK......I'll Rephrase this............

Phil Robertson is LOVED by the Majority of the People that KNOW who he is.........

Craig James is HATED by the Vast Majority of the People that KNOW who he is.............

:)
 

witness23

Veteran Expediter
This guy has a pretty good message for those getting all bent out of shape because of this Phil controversy. I do not agree with his comments on religion(he's obviously an Atheist) but to the finer point of what is actually happening here, he is spot on.

Adult Content Warning: EXPLICIT, UNCENSORED material of a MATURE, ADULT nature is included in the following video

 

Brisco

Expert Expediter
This guy has a pretty good message for those getting all bent out of shape because of this Phil controversy. I do not agree with his comments on religion(he's obviously an Atheist) but to the finer point of what is actually happening here, he is spot on.

Took just 1 Minute of this Blow Hard to realize he's just one of those "Ignorant Idiots" that may last 1/2 hour at some social event until the Host tells him.....and his Opinions...... to Get The Hell out of their house.

Couldn't you find another example to come up with?????
 

paullud

Veteran Expediter
Martin Bashir said something ugly about Sarah Palin. Was MSNBC right in firing him?

No, we need free speech in our society. (Note I used the term free speech not to be confused with 1st amendment) When we close the doors to people being able to talk openly and honestly we stop progress, people will still hate just not openly.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using EO Forums mobile app
 

aristotle

Veteran Expediter
Phil Robertson is guilty of nothing more than being a Southern rural white evangelical Christian. Tens of millions, perhaps one hundred million Americans, might philosophically align themselves with Phil's views in general. Phil's life is a story about redemption. A rascal in his early days, Robertson found salvation through Christ after years of hedonistic living.

Is there any greater power than forgiveness or second chances? Duck Dynasty's broad appeal is built upon these very themes. Phil Robertson sought forgiveness from his Creator, his wife and their four sons as relates to misdeeds of his early adulthood. The family healed. We all should be so lucky as to secure forgiveness.

Mr. Robertson is not an uneducated man. Trained as a schoolteacher, he holds two university degrees. Better educated than the average American, Phil Robertson is, or was, indifferent to politically correct persuasion. A self-made man whose success came late in life. By his own admission, he feels compelled to spread the religious gospel as he is given the light to see it.


Sensitive viewers of A&E might find Robertson's interview remarks to be the crude, unvarnished utterances of an old man woefully out of touch with modern social graces. To those who identify with Phil's social, cultural and religious values... there is hope the Robertson family will move beyond A&E's cowardice and hypocrisy. Move to a bigger format where freedom of expression doesn't bow to bullying.
 

cheri1122

Veteran Expediter
Driver
Do What?????

Can't say that "Stoning Women" has much of an issue here in America for say..........Oh.......What.....12 Years Now?? (Note Hint of Sarcasm.........:p)

To think that "This Decision" of trying to Stifle a LOVED American Icon in the Entertainment Industry was not done in the Vain of Political Correctness is absolutely.............well............Ignorant.

The issue is that Robertson has the right to say whatever he likes and people should accept it, because "it's in the Bible".
So does that mean anything and everything in the Bible is acceptable? Or do people just pick the parts they agree with, and ignore the ones that nobody agrees with anymore? Like stoning women, for example.
And what about his comments on how happy black people were before civil rights? Is that a credible belief?
"Loved American icon"? The man who said this? [Referring to homosexuals, in a speech in Pottstown, Pa's Berean Bible Church]

"They're full of murder, envy, strife, hatred. They are insolent and arrogant God haters. They are heartless, faithless, senseless, ruthless."

I know a few homosexuals, and Mr Robertson is not just appallingly ignorant, he is as wrong as any human ever has been, or could be.
 

mxzane933

Seasoned Expediter
I don't think anything was ignorant, the fact that homosexuals are the most whiney people and that they slammed someone for how they felt and isn't that the very thing they have been fighting for ? People to not judge cuz their feelings? The dudes straight married a pillar of light one woman , married how long now, he likes the female body and he simply thinks a females God sent special place is more appealing than the turd dumper, and from a non biblical position you can't argue is if homosexuality is okay then why is nature against it, if it was right two men could reproduce, good thing Adam didn't pee fairy dust cuz this argument wouldn't be happening we would be non existent .

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using EO Forums mobile app
 

paullud

Veteran Expediter
I don't think anything was ignorant, the fact that homosexuals are the most whiney people and that they slammed someone for how they felt and isn't that the very thing they have been fighting for ? People to not judge cuz their feelings? The dudes straight married a pillar of light one woman , married how long now, he likes the female body and he simply thinks a females God sent special place is more appealing than the turd dumper, and from a non biblical position you can't argue is if homosexuality is okay then why is nature against it, if it was right two men could reproduce, good thing Adam didn't pee fairy dust cuz this argument wouldn't be happening we would be non existent .

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using EO Forums mobile app

Exactly, they are a bunch of hypocrites. They wanted to be heard and now that people are listening they are using their voices to silence anyone that doesn't agree.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using EO Forums mobile app
 

OntarioVanMan

Retired Expediter
Owner/Operator
I don't think anything was ignorant, the fact that homosexuals are the most whiney people and that they slammed someone for how they felt and isn't that the very thing they have been fighting for ? People to not judge cuz their feelings? The dudes straight married a pillar of light one woman , married how long now, he likes the female body and he simply thinks a females God sent special place is more appealing than the turd dumper, and from a non biblical position you can't argue is if homosexuality is okay then why is nature against it, if it was right two men could reproduce, good thing Adam didn't pee fairy dust cuz this argument wouldn't be happening we would be non existent .

Sent from my DROID BIONIC using EO Forums mobile app

No, the Adam and Eve theory justifies Incest...........Tell me ....when Adam and Eve had 3 sons, who did that child mate with?.....
 
Last edited:
Top