Wow, what a cool thread!
One of my carriers main focus is servicing their own customers and will use the boards to keep trucks moving.
One of my carriers focuses on the alliance but 60% of their business is from broker calls.
Another carrier focuses on NLM loads and their own customers and has for years.
One carrier does a mix of all that.
I think I have an awesome mix. Granted my van may be posted by several carriers but I only allow one carrier to bid on each load for me. The first one to call gets to bid it. I personally think it would be stupid have my partners bidding against each other to see who can get me the least money. Has that happened? Sure it has, but I try my best to make sure it doesn't happen. All these carriers have relationships with many different brokers and shippers and I benefit from that.
No disrespect Rocketman but most of my carriers and their dispatchers care very much about the rate they are bidding. Most dispatch teams are commission based and the more money they get the more money they make. Most of my carriers will ask me before bidding what I have to have to run the load, I tell them, they add a certain percentage to it and away we go.
The "over flow" carriers wouldn't exist if there wasnt a need for them. Many aren't actually overflow though when they are filling in the gaps of an existing customer base, just like every other carrier. I understand how having 20 vehicles posted in an area when in actuality there may only be 8 drivers can have a negetive affect on rates but there are solutions to that as well. It would just take a small tweak at the bid board level.
If both Selectus and NLM would assign life long driver numbers. Example is ABC Expedite sings on PreacherRich as a driver they assign him a driver # that will follow him with every carrier he ever runs with. ABC posts PreacherRich available in Laredo and show all the companies he is running with and only show one vehicle. It would also give shippers and brokers a true picture of who is hauling their frieght. They can give the drivers a score just like they do with carriers. It would also eliminate bad drivers from jumping carrier to carrier or fleet owner to fleet owner when you can look up their performance history. Just a thought..it would put an end to "ARTIFICIAL CAPACITY"
Not sure how you can control what carriers are bidding or not bidding for you. If you tell 3 carriers that you are empty in Chicago, don't all 3 go to work trying to load you?
Sylectus is a dispatch software. They would have no interest in doing seething like that and most carriers on the multi unit model would be opposed as it is not Sylectus's business. They would feel they need to butt out and stick to being a software company.
As for companies like NLM, why would they care. Lower rates for them represent a value to their customer. That benefits their customer and them.