If the iphone was offered as they are in other places, unlocked and not tied to any one company, it may be worth getting but AT&T, the people who bring you dropped calls in major markets plan have a rather monopoly on the iPhone and services.
FWIW, quite awhile ago we dumped
Verizon due to too many dropped calls and limited coverage in a particular area (about an hour due west of DC) and went with ATT.
While we do have still have occasional dropped calls with ATT (don't they all ?
) it hasn't been an insurmountable issue. Interestingly, to some extent, it may well depend on who you are talking to - both in terms of the carrier they have, and the phone they are using:
I have one expediter friend who has both Sprint and Nextel phones, and a couple of others that have Verizon - I can talk to the two with Verizon often for hours on end, many times when one - or either of us - are rolling down the road.
Although we haven't tracked every dropped call and entered it in a database for statistical analysis
, it seems from observing who had no bars, as though the occurrence of dropped calls is spread fairly evenly between me and the two with Verizon (IOW, it could be either one of us)
When I, or the two with Verizon, try and talk to the guy with Sprint/Nextel we are lucky to get in a 5 minute conversation before the call drops - not to mention that the voice quality one of the two (dunno if it's Sprint or Nextel) is horrific - almost always unintelligible. This happens time ... after time .... after time ......
MUSH, he was our salesman, didn't try and sell us on any particular phone, he did answer all my questions concerning dropped calls, which phone would be better for on the road. This bit of info, convinced me not to get the IPhone. 3G technology uses multiple satellites. Most calls that are dropped occur during a switch.
Dunno about that - this I do know however: I've had an iPhone 3G for almost a year now.
Prior to that I had Sony T-616 (Tri-band, GSM) which I had had for about 5 years or so. The difference in terms of dropped calls between the two is enormous - the iPhone 3G is an order of magnitude better. Be interesting to know how the iPhone 3Gs fares, in terms of it's cellular capabilities ....
It has plenty of toys like IM, email, camera yet is not a 3G. .... <snip> ... For my business, I need a phone that is the most reliable while on the road, not the most fun.
When my Garmin GPS died an untimely death while out on the road, I used the GPS in my iPhone
for several weeks, until I could get back home to pick up the replacement. The iPhone worked like a charm .... although I much prefer the Garmin.
As to the "toy" aspect ..... I know that Lawrence has an iPhone .... so he
understands the degree that it is, or can be, a
highly practical tool ....
A toy .... yeah, I suppose that it could be that too ... if that's what you choose to do with it. Seeing it as
only that would be .....
a rather limited view .....
I was talking to a friend of mine after I got the iPhone - we are both longtime Apple/Mac users - and commented to him about how useful I was finding it (despite the fact that I've never really expended much time or effort in bothering to learning all the details)
He relayed an observation that was made in an article he had read in one of the computer rags:
"Most people believe that the iPhone is a phone - it's not - it's a fairly powerful computer that is very, very easy to use ..... that just happens to have a phone and some other stuff built into it."
To paraphrase my Sprint/Nextel friend, who has, what I assume are, a couple of fairly nice phones (although the service to appears to be pretty crappy), after showing him my iPhone and letting him play with it for 5 minutes or so:
"Man .... I ain't got nuthin' ....."
Yeah, Lawrence - just do it.