Be wary of anyone who boasts he or she has a good deal on health insurance. The devil is in the details and a close look at any plan will likely flush out some surprises.
Diane and I are reviewing our options now. Each insurance company lists a host of features and prices. The thing to do is develop a spreadsheet that lists most if not all of the items covered and the amount you would pay for each of them under a given scenario. Then choose a plan based on what you learn and what is best for you.
Come up with a half-dozen scenarios for a full analysis. Examples:
1. We (married couple) we are healthy all year and each require only new eyeglasses, two routine trips to the dentist, a physical exam that includes blood work and a mammogram.
2. We are traveling out of network and are both injured in an accident that requires ambulance, ER and a week of hospitalization and six follow up appointments for physical therapy.
3. Scenario 1 above but also one of us is diagnosed with diabetes and goes on insulin.
4. One of us is diagnosed with cancer and chemotherapy and surgery is required.
Below is a partial list of items from our spreadsheet used to compare plans. Each item is given its own row on the spreadsheet. For each insurance company being considered, put its name at the top of a column. When the spreadsheet is complete, bring a scenario to mind and work your way down a column to total up what you would pay if that scenario played out in real life.
There is some overlap in the row titles because different companies describe their items in different ways. In such cases, create a row for each item. It's OK if two items overlap. Simply ignore the rows that do not fit a company and use the row that best matches the item as a given company describes it.
Monthly Premium
Deductible
Co-Insurance
Max Out of Pocket
ER Care
Generic Drugs
Preferred Brand Drugs
Non-Preferred Brand Drugs
Specialty Drugs
Preventative Care
Primary Care Dr. Visit
Specialist Visit
Specialist, Referral Required?
Physicals and Immunizations
Lab Tests and Blood Work
Mammogram
Colonoscopy
Mail Order Generic Drugs
Urgent Care
Depression, Diabetes, Asthma, High Blood Pressure, High Cholesterol
(Specific conditions if the insurance company lists them)
Hospital Co-Pay
Ambulatory Surgical
Outpatient Hospital
Provider/Surgeon Fee
Inpatient Hospital
Imaging
Ambulance
Diagnostic (Lab, etc)
Additional Feature
Out of Network Coverage