Sleep needs and their relationship to safety are individual. Some may do better on the 10 hour rule, others on a 5 and 5. NO law/regulation takes that into account. The 5 and 5 was, without a doubt, safer for OUR operation. No own can "prove" this, there are just far too many variables. As many variables as there are drivers.
OK I guess if you want to look at it in a myopic version of reality but no matter if you can figure out a way to write a regulation that allows those who want to chase the pennies safely while not allowing others who can't control their behavior by getting sleep, then there is a job for you in Washington and you be a millionaire in a matter of months.
IT doesn't have a thing to do with this niche market or YOUR operation which is patterned after the needs of your carrier but with the fact that it HAS TO apply to everyone by the lowest common denominator.
I can't prove there is oxygen in the air. I can't prove the 5/5 rule. I can't prove many other things. I am not equipped or trained to do so. I still know them and I am correct. You will find many teams who will tell you they are much more alert and safe on a 5/5 than on a 10/10. When I ran team that was the case.
If you can't prove Air has O2 in it, then you shouldn't be driving.
Again repeating this, IT doesn't have a thing to do with this niche market or YOUR operation which is patterned after the needs of your carrier but with the fact that it HAS TO apply to everyone by the lowest common denominator.
Well another friendly deal from the Obama croneys. I wonder how much more friendly he can be towards business. Trucking companys cannot fill seats now and if that goes through, more seats will be emptied. Isn't he doing a wonderful and fullfilling job for American? Oh my did I say that??
Well guess what?
THIS wasn't started under Obama but under Bush and it was his administration who was caught with their hands in the cookie jar. AND because of that the court told them to rewrite it properly which of course they can't.
Trucking companies don't seem to have a problem filling their trucks with people who can drive but they have a problem with maintaining the level of competence with those drivers after they are pushed through training. Maybe we need to actually think of it this way - the training here sucks and the license is too easy to get.