The problem is, Melissa, we still don't know who, when, how and why the dipstick was broken. If you go back to that thread and read the original post, which is what the comments you took offense to were based upon, it would have been impossible to check the oil level in a pre-trip. OVM posted what he did as a way to get blood out of a turnip (A.K.A. get more information out of Dave, which typically takes about six or eight posts from Dave). Dave failed to enlighten us in any subsequent posts how long the dipstick had been broken, or even how it got broken.
For all we know, it's been broken for weeks and it's been that long since the oil level was checked.
Based on the information that was posted, a legitimate question was asked, that of 'just how did you expect a driver to check the oil during a pretrip?' Since the dipstick was broken, and it's impossible to check the oil level during a pretrip without one, then false pretrip reports must be being filed. There is no other conclusion that can be reached based on the information provided. To reach some other less offensive conclusion, one must make assumptions based on information we haven't seen.
Rather than going batcrap crazy over OVMs comments and accusations, despite others having the same questions about all the things that didn't add up, it seems to me it would have been easier for Dave to quickly clear up that issue by simply stating when and how the dipstick got broken. If it was broken that day by and at the repair shop, then the logical assumption would be that pre-trips were indeed possible, and very probable.
Interestingly, the issue of when and how the dipstick was broken has been questioned several times, and he has yet to give an answer. Is it because he doesn't want to admit that it's been broken for days or weeks? What conclusion, if any, can be drawn from that? Why would you or Big Cat be offended by questions regarding another truck's dipstick? Or is it the truck you drive?