THE BEST FOOD IN INDIANA?????

dhalltoyo

Veteran Expediter
Dear Friends,

It is not my desire to contend with anyone, but for those who rave about the food at Garcia's in Columbus, IN...well

I went there for lunch today.

First, I immediately noticed that the majority of the employees were local Hoosiers! Hey, if it's Mexican then the employees should also be Mexican.

Second, I walked in and sat down at a table. After no one came to wait on me I began to look around and watch folks enter in restaurant and walk to a hallway on one side of interior. OK, I got up and stood in line to place my order. They had little menus taped on the wall in the hallway, but I didn't see what I wanted. When I got to the window I asked if they had Chimicangas. They did have them, but is having menus on the tables too much to ask. I felt a little rushed with folks standing behind me.

Third, they don't take plastic! Now I have to walk back to the truck and get my checkbook.

Fourth, I finally am able to actually pay for the meal which was a whooping $14.79. One Chimichanga, a few beans, a little rice, a bowl with some warm bean dip, a handful of chips and a flan for desert. They food was decent and fresh, but it was like eating a glorified snack! Truthfully, the flan was the best part of that meal.

Fifth, the salsa comes in squirt bottles. Duh! Whatever happened to bowls for dipping?

Sixth, they close down during the winter months!

Finally, let me tell you about a place where you can get EXCELLENT AUTHENTIC MEXICAN FOOD that is prepared and served by MEXICANS! You will get a meal that you probably can not finish. Your basket of Salsa Chips will be warm, delicious, crunchy and refilled whenever it it empty!

My favorite is a Triple Fajita with beef, chicken and shimp served sizzling on a cast iron plate. Plenty of beans, rice, lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese with Guacamole on top the veggies. All that plus all-you-can-eat Salsa Chips with BOWLS of salsa. They will bring hot and mild salsa to the table.

For desert check out the FRIED MEXICAN ICE CREAM. It is so good it will make your tongue slap your brains out.

These folks began with one restaurant in Dayton, Ohio. They now have three locations. I am inclding the directions for the location that is within one mile of Interstate 75.

I-75 to Exit 44 which is south of Dayton
Turn west onto SR 725 towards Miamisburg
Turn right (north) at the third traffic light onto S. Alex Rd
Turn right (east) at the next intersection onto Watertower Lane
Make an immediate left (north) at the first street. You can see this street runs behind a small strip mall. Straight trucks park down near the north end of the strip mall and vans can go into the parking lot.
El Rancho Grande is at the north end of the strip mall.

PS. You will be so impressed with the food you will probably call me and invite me over for lunch. LOL
 

cheri1122

Veteran Expediter
Driver
So maybe my 'bad luck' was, after all good luck - I tried to visit Garcia's earlier this week, as I was headed north through Indiana on Sunday. I figured it would be too late for Sunday dinner, but thought I might detour back after my Mon morning delivery, for lunch. I got the phone number, map, etc. from Streets & Trips, & called to inquire about the hours. [They don't answer the phone, either, & say so on the recorded announcement!] So, guess which 2 days they're not open? I still would like to try it, because I love good Mexican food, and now I want to try the one you suggest, too - the description made me hungry, lol. Thanks for the heads up, and in return I'd suggest the Mercado Juarez in Dallas/Ft Worth, at 35W, exit 53 - the carnitas are the best I've ever had.
Anyone have any other great places to eat, Mexican or otherwise? :)
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
I was in the Chicagoe area last year and stopped in this hole in the wall dump of a former taco bell - don't ask why i stopped. All mexicans and had a good menu. They made the food right in front of you and it was huge. Well the owner gave me his card and one side is his info on the reverse is his brothers info of his place in Indy.

Isn't there a place in the Indy area that has these really huge burritos?

On the west side of indy by the mall on the loop there is a really good chinese place.

If you are in Detroit by the bridge and have to wait to cross in the afternoon, down Bagely is Mexican viliage, nice place. Across the freeways is the other Mexican places. There used to be Elaine's on Vernor on the other side, but now it is a south american place - still good food. If you decide to eat anywhere around there, get carry out and eat in the truck - remember this is Detroit.
 

Lawrence

Founder
Staff member
David,

Thanks for the post and feedback on Garcia's in Columbus, IN.

I still stand-by my statement that Garcia's is the best Mexican food in Indiana - but I should have clarified that it is TEX-MEX, not Mexican food.

Some obvious differences are that Tex-Mex:

- Uses white corn tortilla chips etc instead of hard yellow corn.
- Heavy use of chili.
- Influence of Northern Mexico and South-west Texas.
- Ample use of Beef.
- Cowboy food influence.

What we know as Mexican food in the Midwest is from regions in Mexico like Monterrey and Acapulco with a strong indigenous Indian influence. Tex-Mex has a more Spanish flavor.

Keep in mind that Tex-Mex has been in Texas and parts of the US for 200 + Years.

Also, Garcia's in Columbus, IN has been there for 37 years - long before the current Mexican Food invasion.

To get a great taste of true TEX-MEX outside of Indiana is Ninfa's in Houston and Dallas, Mariachis in San Antonio and El Phoenix in Dallas.

Happy Eating!

Lawrence,
Expediters Online.com


T.V. - Why do you think they call it programming?

No, YOU suck. - the mean people

"Americans are benevolently ignorant about Canada, while Canadians are malevolently well informed about the United States." - J. Bartlett Brebner

Te audire no possum. Musa sapientum fixa est in aure. - I can't hear you. I have a banana in my ear.

Become who you are. - Nietzsche


Whoever coined the phrase "Quiet as a mouse" has never stepped on one.




-----------------------------------------
Thanks For Visiting EO!
[p]
http://www.expeditersonline.com/hotnews/sterling_eo_forum.jpg


Please Help Us Get The Word
Out About Expediters Online.com!

-----------------------------------------
 

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
OK, first it isn't mexican food but the title says best food not best mexican food and second I haven't had the chance to stop in so I only have reports to repeat. That said, Carmel, IN is home to Bub's Big Ugly Burger which is a one pound hamburger and supposed to be the best hamburger you've ever put in your mouth. I'm looking forward to eventually trying it.

Leo Bricker, 73's K5LDB, OOIDA 677319
Owner, Panther trucks 5507, 5508, 5509
Highway Watch Participant, Truckerbuddy
EO Forum Moderator
----------
Support the entire Constitution, not just the parts you like.
 

dhalltoyo

Veteran Expediter
TEX-MEX or not, the review centered on portion size, service and price.

Garcia's is grossly over-priced and the service is poor at best.

The flavor was fair, but the other aspects sorely diminish my rating of this location.

Moreover, they are closed 4 months out of the year! And they don't take plastic which is a real drawback for those who live on the road.

Again, the next time your are in Dayton try the Chimichangas at El Rancho Grande. Just like Garcia's, they use shredded beef; not hamburger! You will be TEX-MEXY happy with your meal.
 

Lawrence

Founder
Staff member
David,

Fair enough.

Lawrence,
Expediters Online.com


T.V. - Why do you think they call it programming?

No, YOU suck. - the mean people

"Americans are benevolently ignorant about Canada, while Canadians are malevolently well informed about the United States." - J. Bartlett Brebner

Te audire no possum. Musa sapientum fixa est in aure. - I can't hear you. I have a banana in my ear.

Become who you are. - Nietzsche


Whoever coined the phrase "Quiet as a mouse" has never stepped on one.




-----------------------------------------
Thanks For Visiting EO!
[p]
http://www.expeditersonline.com/hotnews/sterling_eo_forum.jpg


Please Help Us Get The Word
Out About Expediters Online.com!

-----------------------------------------
 
Top