Fish,
It sounds like you are a dispatcher.
Well tell you the truth, the idea was not really to have the hundreds of dispatchers to come to EO (or my site) to read what I think or demand what they have to do but to get a few to think about their practices and by thinking about things, improve their performance. Oh yea and I wrote it to vent.
As a matter of fact, I don’t think that it was all as ineffective at all, as you may think, I have a few dialogs on going with company managers and a VP on what I think and how to improve things within the dispatching staff and may lead back to consulting for me (who knows?). Two companies have asked permission to use the list, which all this makes me think that I have come up with something that they can use which will lead to being better for all of us.
By the way, this really wasn’t a target of smaller companies but truthfully they can use it more effectively than larger ones.
As for what others have thought of this from the position as a driver and this is from a driver’s point of view only, it is not. Been there, done that from driver to manager in a rather large transportation department and in a company where you didn’t mess around. I didn’t spend a lot of time as a manager but on my way up, I took part in training and hiring/firing.
I find that companies are improving on their customer service performance but it seems to me that many dispatchers are underpaid and in some cases dumbfounded about how to handle many different situations, as are many managers. Maybe I am thinking from a true customer service point of view, but as I said the list is not the way I like it with some redundancy, it is getting revised some time in the future to eliminate the redundancy and make it more concise.