I have done some driving that was unsafe in my time. The problem with the vans is that it is hard to make money unless you drive a lot of miles. Some companies pay a higher rate but you still have to crank out the miles to make money. Regulation would be good. There are people who die in vans because they fall asleep behind the wheel. Also some of these shippers are insane with how fast they want these loads delivered and the type of miles they think a person can driver safely.
What is the real difference between a semi truck and a cargo van? Oh the semi truck kills more people is the reasoning behind why the vans should not be regulated. I think if the cargo vans were regulated and the rates got higher by weeding out some of the riff raff it would be a good thing. If vans are regulated then all of them junk trucks that cannot pass a DOT inspection will be gone! The drivers who cannot pass a DOT Physical will be gone, and those who cannot pass a hazmat background check will be gone. Then we can begin the discussion on newer vehicles and higher rates for cargo vans.
Good grief. OK, first, if you want to make as much money in a cargo van that you can in a straight truck, then yes, you have to drive a lot of miles. But you don't have to drive them unsafely. In any case, the vast majority of expedite line haul lengths do not even present a situation where you have to drive tired, and those that do usually have time to get the necessary rest. The wacko carriers and cargo van drivers which are exceptions to the norm are no different than the wacko carriers and drivers of regulated vehicles who skirt the regulations they are supposed to drive under.
Second,
What is the real difference between a semi truck and a cargo van? Oh the semi truck kills more people is the reasoning behind why the vans should not be regulated.
The difference is that, but it's more than that. The DOT regulates heavy trucks and buses, and the transport of hazardous materials, because heavy trucks and buses and hazardous materials pose an unreasonable risk to the general public. Cargo vans do not. In fact, the commercial cargo van accident and casualty rate, according to the NHTSA, exactly mirrors that of the general public of passenger cars and light trucks.
"The drivers who cannot pass a DOT Physical will be gone, and those who cannot pass a hazmat background check will be gone."
They're already gone if they cannot pass a DOT physical. Few carriers allow drivers with or without a CDL to drive for them without passing a DOT physical. The insurance companies simply won't allow it.
Drivers of unregulated cargo vans who cannot pass a HAZMAT background check can't haul HAZMAT. Interestingly enough, drivers of regulated trucks who cannot pass a HAZMAT background check can't haul HAZMAT, either. I don't see very many van drivers or CMV drivers being "gone" because of that.
So, the only justification that can be given for cargo vans to be regulated is, and said in the most whiny, adolescent
waaa, waaa, waaa voice you can imagine,
"Well if I have to log and scale then they should toooooo!!!" And then stomp your foot real hard a couple of times to drive it home.