Yeah, you're right. I didn't read the book. I'm too cheap to buy it.
Like Bigdogg says, it's also available for free online.
The problem with free online, as I see it, is the tendency to take it in piecemeal rather than getting the big picture of it all. It's not about cutting back on or cutting out carbs, it's about the reasons for it, what your body does under certain conditions, when and how to eat the right carbs, etc. You can certainly get all that online, but I just think it's better to read the book and have a fuller understanding of what all you're doing and why. Also, online, especially at the Atkins site, they tend to promote the products they're selling, and you don't want to get too caught up in that. If you're not careful, the Atkins products can be a crutch you're better off not having to rely on. It's the same with the book, actually.
The
"NEW Atkins for a New You" is the latest book, but it, like the online information from Atkins, is rather weak. The Atkins people have bowed to, and are catering to, public perceptions and mainstream thinking (largely to sell more Atkins products). Dr Atkins is rolling over in his grave. His original book,
"Dr. Atkins' New Diet Revolution" by Robert C. Atkins himself was radical and controversial, but this new book written by these new Atkins people is written so that it won't upset anyone, especially anyone who would write about the Atkins diet in the press. Bad press upsets the apple cart, and and upset people won't buy your products.
You don't need Atkins products, or "special" diabetic meals if you are diabetic. Instead, you just need to eat right. You don't need fancy gimmicks or high tech food substitutes to lose weight. You just need to eat right. For example, butter is insanely more healthy for you than margarine is. Just don't put butter on white toast or pancakes. You do that and the butter becomes artery spackle. But butter on broccoli is perfectly fine and healthy. Well, maybe not for YOU, but it is for anyone not on blood thinners.
Margarine, and all trans fats (hydrogenated and partially hydrogenated), for example, contains a molecule not found in nature. It's no wonder your body doesn't know what to do with it. And it's why ingesting trans fats has a direct linear trend between trans fatty acid intake and LDL cholesterol concentration, and therefore increased risk of coronary heart disease. It doesn't matter if you are genetically predisposed or not. The heart, skeletal system and brain all use fatty acids to metabolize nutrients and for fuel, but trans fatty acids cannot be used by the body in any way. Since they aren't processed by the body, their presence results in a dramatic increase of the very bad LDL cholesterol (which again increases insulin resistance in trying in vain to use it for fuel, and increased metabolic resistance because the enzymes triggered by the insulin are otherwise occupied). Over time, months or years, that'll bite you in the arterial butt.
In the original book Dr Atkins articulates the science behind the philosophy so clear that anyone could understand it, and yet so detailed that any doctor schooled in the mainstream thinking could learn from it. In the new book, bowing to mainstream thinking and without the science to back it up, they tell you that you have to be careful with your fat intake and may have to count calories, which not only goes against what Dr Atkins teaches, but goes against the irrefutable science of it. In fact, the new book doesn't talk much at all about the science. Knowledge is power, and the original book gives you the knowledge and the power that the new book lacks utterly.
I have big problems with portion control. I continue to stuff myself silly even after I am full to the max. My brain just keeps on screaming eat, eat, eat.
Been there, done that, got the t-shirt, my friend. I understand completely.
It used to be that one Subway foot long didn't really even fill me up. Now if I eat one I'm bloated and worthless the rest of the day. Like bigdogg says, if you do the Atkins Induction Phase, and eat something several times a day instead of once (like I used to do) or twice, the cravings go away very quickly. Like, within a week. After that you will rarely crave anything.
I'm not a structured person. I go to sleep and wake up at all different time of the day and night. That is why it is hard for me to maintain a steady schedule of eating.
Same here. That's also the nature of expediting, which makes it doubly hard. Eating several times a day is still my biggest difficulty. After a lifetime of eating once or twice a day, eating several times a day is a hard habit to get into, even when I'm at home and have nothing else distracting me from eating. Couple that with expediting where any set routine is meaningless, and it's a significant problem for me.
Several years ago I was on Atkins and did very well. Then circumstance changed and my routine was shot, and I gradually went back to quick and easy, and got off the diet. But since being diagnosed with diabetes last fall, with the possibility down the road of having to go on insulin, and with a BMI of 44 staring me in the face and knowing the likelihood of having to deal with the DOT Doctors about that down the road, watching what I eat and losing weight became the only viable option. I'm certainly motivated. I've gone from 300 pounds to 240 since October, not by going on the Atkins diet per se, but by using the knowledge I gained from the book. I don't eat anything without thinking about what, exactly, it will do to my body. Initially that consideration was about what it would do to my blood sugar, whether it will spike it or not. Then it was about getting cholesterol down, and getting weight off which helps with both glucose and cholesterol levels, as well as increasing metabolism. But coincidentally, those same considerations are the foundation of the Atkins diet.
When I was first diagnosed with diabetes, I went on a quasi-Induction Phase of Atkins. I didn't count carbs, but I did eliminate any that would spike by blood sugar. I was able to do that successfully because I've read the book and understand it all. For example, since last fall I have only eaten potatoes in any form (mashed) once, and even then I was sure to eat the proper foods before and with the potatoes to ensure the normally fast digesting starch in potatoes didn't spike my blood sugar.
My goal is to look like a prion camp survivor by the end of this year. If this doesn't work I'm going to have switch to the banana diet. You know that 60MPH lost over a hundred pounds eating bananas, fiber supplements, and water? Any how, thanks for the advice.
You also want to be careful about losing weight too fast. Losing weight too fast also puts stress on the body. Bananas are good, but too many, or even eaten at the wrong time (depending on what other foods you have eaten recently) can be very bad, as it messes with both insulin and metabolic resistance. You have to balance the bananas with plenty of fat and protein, otherwise, as Amonger noted, the nutrients in the bananas cannot be utilized by the body, which increases insulin resistance, raises cholesterol, increases the plaque in the arteries and raises blood pressure. 60MPH, who was a friend of mine, lost 100 pounds eating primarily bananas, fiber and water, and then promptly died of a heart attack.
Any dramatic change in diet will cause a stress to the body, even the Atkins Diet does that. But the Atkins Diet, using the science behind it all, is less stressful than the others. Everything you eat causes the body to react to that food metabolically. Good foods eaten in the proper amounts and proper combinations cause the body to react positively. Bad foods or bad combinations do just the opposite. With the science behind Atkins, everything you're eating is for a specific nutritional purpose to invoke a specific controlled metabolic reaction in the body, with you in control and in full knowledge of what's going on and why. That's important, especially in the long run. In the short term, cutting back or eliminating "anything white" is good, but unless you know the whys and wherefores, it cannot work long term.
There are no tricks or gimmicks to losing weight. There is no shortcut. You have to learn to eat right, and learn why things happen when you eat certain things. Anecdotes from friends and online forums can be helpful, but it's mostly superficial and lacks a certain understanding and knowledge. The original Atkins book gives you that knowledge.
But even if you don't actually
do Atkins, doing what you are doing now is certainly better than continuing to do what you've been doing. I still strongly encourage you to get some big picture knowledge that will give you the knowledge to deal with the details.
If you don't learn anything at all from Atkins or don't want to read the book, know this: Don't eat invented foods. And mostly eat stuff that comes to you in God's packaging. When you go to the grocery store, do your shopping around the perimeter of the store and stay out of the center aisles. If you can do those three things, you'll eat healthier by default.