Indiana latest US state to drop handwriting requirement

EnglishLady

Veteran Expediter
BBC News

Indiana is the latest US state which will not require its schoolchildren to learn joined-up, or cursive, writing.

But students will have to learn basic typing skills, which education officials say are more useful in the modern employment world.

The move is part of the Common Core State Standards Initiative, which aims to ensure consistency in US education and makes no mention of handwriting.

But critics say writing well is a vital skill for life and builds character.

US schoolchildren currently learn to write with joined-up writing from about the age of eight.

But under the core standards - which were released in June 2010 and have been adopted by nearly all US states - there is no requirement for them to do so.

'Progressive'

Children from grade six upwards - about 11 years old - will, however, be expected to "demonstrate sufficient command of keyboarding skills to type a minimum of three pages in a single sitting".

Many schools have said there simply is not enough time in the term to teach children both.

Dr Scott Hamilton, an Indiana clinical psychologist, said the time children spend labouring over script could be better used

"From an intuitive standpoint, this makes sense, based on the increasingly digital world into which this generation of children is growing up," he said.

Denna Renbarger, an education official in Lawrence Township, Indiana, said there were many more important things for students to be learning at school

"I think it's progressive of our state to be ahead on this," she told the Indianapolis Star.

Indiana officials have stressed that the standards are not exhaustive and that teachers could continue teaching handwriting if they chose.

But some parents, teachers and psychologists have reacted angrily to the move, saying there is more to handwriting than being able to write quickly.

"The fluidity of cursive allows for gains in spelling and a better tie to what they are reading and comprehending through stories and through literature," Paul Sullivan, head teacher of a school in California, told CNN.

"I think there's a firmer connection of wiring between the brain's processes of learning these skills and the actual practice of writing."

Parent Jerry Long told the Indianapolis Star he was worried about what the new system could mean for his sixth grade daughter in the future.

"I don't agree with it. How are they supposed to know how to sign their names?"
 

chefdennis

Veteran Expediter
"typing" use to be part of the "basic business class I took as a freshman in HS...now it will be taught in 1st grade....:rolleyes:
 

EnglishLady

Veteran Expediter
"typing" use to be part of the "basic business class I took as a freshman in HS...now it will be taught in 1st grade....


What a changing world we live in :rolleyes:

I wonder if they are allowed to type in text :confused:

I wndr r u alwd 2 tpe n txt


or something like that ROFL :D:p
 

chefdennis

Veteran Expediter
Sue wrote:

I wonder if they are allowed to type in text

I wndr r u alwd 2 tpe n txt


or something like that ROFL

I am sure they will!! Its not like most of them can "spell"...and besides, they can eliminate the spelling classes and test because pointing out there spelling mistake would be bad on their "self esteem"...and we can't have them feeling bad
 

chefdennis

Veteran Expediter
yes they do...but it is "recognition" based, not spelling or typing....but then again i think "ebonics" was also "recognition based..it certainly was based on "proper spelling"...:rolleyes:
 

Turtle

Administrator
Staff member
Retired Expediter
I don't see a problem in eliminating cursive (or joined-up writing for you Brits) in school. The need for it simply doesn't exist anymore. The romantics who see writing as art will tell you that being able to write a legible and pleasant cursive longhand is an essential part of rational life. That forming well-made letters with the hand while forming thoughts in the mind is not the same as tapping little plastic squares while mechanical fonts appear on a screen and the cursor relentlessly blinks like a faucet that won’t stop dripping. That's largely horse hockey. The pleasure of handwriting has always been with us and it is not going to go away. But you cannot force that pleasure onto anyone who takes no pleasure in it. Some take great pleasure in a computer console and abhor the thought of having to write a letter in longhand.

It is true, I think, that the practice of handwriting infuses many desirable character qualities. Regard for the reader in the striving for maximum legibility being paramount, but also the training and development of the aesthetic sense in the letters, spacing, and overall texture, the discrimination in avoiding poor proportions, as well as having to concentrate on both spelling and the thought that is about to be committed to paper. The clarity and precision needed for good legibility trains us in our thoughts, and the sentences which create them.

But other than artsy aesthetics which go back to Egyptian times even, the origins and primary reasons of the cursive style (or, again, joined-up :D) is associated solely with the practical advantages of faster writing speed while remaining legible, of not having to lift up that ink-laden quill pen after every letter to avoid drips and smudges, and, the individuality and distinctiveness of provenance of a document, as opposed to the mundane utilitarianism of machined documents.

Writing has evolved much since its beginnings, and it will continue to do so. But cursive and other styles, like calligraphy, will always be with us. But, here's an interesting article from the Washington Post in 2006. Read both pages, especially the part about kids and cursive.
The Handwriting Is on the Wall

Did you know... On July 4, 1776 the Declaration of Independence was approved by the thirteen colonies and on July 19 the Continental Congress ordered that the Declaration be "fairly engrossed on parchment" and signed by every member of Congress. As a clerk to the Secretary of the Continental Congress (Charles Thomson of Philadelphia), a guy named Timothy Matlack (delegate from Pennsylvania) was chosen to inscribe the historic document that everyone signed and that now rests on display in the National Archives. Most people think the presentation draft was penned by Thomas Jefferson.
 

Tennesseahawk

Veteran Expediter
Personally, I think they should have calligraphy in school. It exercises a different part of the brain than math (logic) does. For centuries, calligraphy was an essential part of education.
 

Dakota

Veteran Expediter
How come British people don't sound British when they sing?
Some I can barely understand when they talk, but can understand them clearly when they sing
 

EnglishLady

Veteran Expediter
How come British people don't sound British when they sing?
Some I can barely understand when they talk, but can understand them clearly when they sing





Ahh you mean local accents ...

Actually a few artists do/did ..... the Beatles comes to mind first :rolleyes:

Martine McCutcheon is another :)
 

Turtle

Administrator
Staff member
Retired Expediter
How come British people don't sound British when they sing?
Some I can barely understand when they talk, but can understand them clearly when they sing
Because unless you make an effort to do otherwise, singing is "accent neutral" regardless of your native language. English vowels sound the same no matter where you are from, and when you sing, you sing the vowels phonetically. And because speech and singling are controlled by different parts of the brain, it's very easy to sing in English without an accent. The members of ABBA, for example, couldn't speak English well enough to order lunch at Taco Bell, but they sang in nearly flawless English. Choral music you can also completely understand, even if it's 150 singers all from different countries, because they're singing phonetically.

Anyone who sings in an accent usually does it on purpose and with great effort. They are also bending vowels, and bending the musical notes (adding new notes that's not part of the music), same as when they talk.

Roight govnah. I luv to lick me lolly on the trolley. :D
 
Top