This is an interesting discussion on your part, Dave.
Perhaps a fleet owner needs to recruit folks that are in the game a year or two, not old hats. The year or twos are still excited enough to stay out for months at a time because they know if they sit a week there is no check two or three weeks down the road.
Last year was a wierd case in point. The year or twos would not take it personal when a company maintenance supervisor calls them to accuse them of stealing a trailer that is assigned to them. They wouldn't have taken the call - they would have had the owner deal with it.
We desperately needed to get to Alabama for example but instead sat at a truckstop in Allentown PA for four days, before we knew about transcore 360. No one called us in the four days we sat there, neither Panther nor the owner. I did not get to say goodbye to my mother, who passed three months later because I could never get to Alabama to see her .
We sat for eight days due to Panther's reefer trailer issue, in the home office area, and lost tremendous dollars because of it. There were empty trucks sitting at our owner's office but we were never offered an opportunity to make any money while Panther had our assigned trailer performing the TVAL tests.
When our property suffered a 24 foot wall of river and ate my car, we were home for 30 hours and dispatched out without a word to us to see how we were, had we done our insurance work, etc. This was after driving to Ohio in our POV Christmas Day, and out until the first of Feb for only those 30 hours to access the damage to our property. We left our house, picked up the overweight load, spun the fan shroud 300 miles from home and sat in Reno for four days waiting for parts so that my husband could repair the truck in the Petro parking lot in a blizzard, then to get to Laredo and the load refused for another three days. Moral hit the floor.
One or two year expediting vets would still be willing to go out for those two or three months after all this because they would hope things would get better. They can be coaxed to take loads that really don't make sense but because they drive for an owner, they accept them.
Veterans know that some areas are not so hot and will wait for another better deal. Veterans also know that when it is very very slow, any offer can be sweetened usually to move to another area and make a few bucks.
No decent teams will want to stay out months away from home for a fleet owner if they have a truck that will fail a DOT spot check. They cannot afford it. Some teams cannot afford to pay all the tolls up front and wait three weeks for reimbursement. Some will not sleep on a mattress that is as old as the truck, some will insist the APU and heat/AC work as if the owner was driving it. The better the equipment, the longer you are willing to stay out and run. Poor equipment, the driver gets tired of breakdowns and babysitting.
With all this said, our team agreed with each of the three expedite owners we drove for that we would run ten months of the year and home eight weeks.
We stayed out for five months other than the 30 hours to check the flood damage and asked for 8 days off. The owner pressured us to come back sooner than we requested for hometime because we were hard runners and made his company money while some of the fleet was not as dedicated or the trucks were empty. Panther dispatched us so that we could keep our hometime intact.
I think that any fleet owner should also be very careful who they hire to manage their drivers and trucks after their drivers have been dealing expressly with the owner. The drivers new liaison may not have the same goals as the fleet owner and sometimes not the same agenda.
If the drivers are not happy, they will not stay out as long as the owner hopes they will. If they are working and the truck is well maintained, and they feel respected by the owner, they may work an extra month before going home.
Remember, the owner goes home at night, sleeps in their bed, has a nice hot shower and a snack in the kitchen. Dispatchers go home at night and sleeps in their bed.
The truck driver lives in the owner's truck. And sacrifices.
Thank goodness I worked as a team with my husband, and we endured every challenge and every triumph together. I could not have done it solo. At least when someone makes you mad you have someone to discuss it with before you say or text something you will regret.
So, drivers who work for others are not likely to stay out as long as owners who drive their own "houses." And if the fleet owner was a driver in the past, they should be somewhat more understanding of what hometime does for morale and encourage regular hometime for their fleet.
Just my two cents