House votes to kill Home Affordable program

Ragman

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
House votes to kill main Obama foreclosure aid

By Corbett B. Daly 2 hrs 57 mins ago
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday voted to kill President Barack Obama's signature program to help struggling homeowners avoid foreclosure.

A bill to terminate the program was approved on a 252-170 vote. But the bill is unlikely to clear the Senate.

It was the last in series of four measures brought forward by newly empowered House Republicans to end government assistance for homeowners hurt by the housing crisis.

Republicans argued the foreclosure prevention plan, known as the Home Affordable Modification Program, is ineffective and not worthy of taxpayer support amid soaring budget deficits. The vote broke largely along party lines.

The program, which offers incentives for lenders to modify loans, was launched to great fanfare in the spring of 2009. The Obama administration had hoped it would permanently lower mortgage payments for 3 million to 4 million homeowners.

But fewer than 600,000 borrowers have received permanent loan modifications, and the program has been widely criticized as ineffective from critics on both the left and the right.

"The HAMP program is a failure," said Representative Patrick McHenry, the North Carolina Republican who sponsored the bill. "If we can't eliminate this failed program, what program can we eliminate?"

Analysts see the votes as an effort by Republicans, who last seized control of the House in an election in November with an anti-bailout, anti-spending message, to score points with their political base.

The White House has already threatened to veto the measure. However, it is unlikely to come to that since Democrats, who retained control of the Senate, largely opposed the measure. Both the House and Senate would have to approve the bill for it to reach the president's desk.

About $30 billion has been set aside for the program from the government's $700 billion financial rescue fund, but only about $1 billion of that has been spent so far.

Democrats argued the program should be fixed, not killed.

"The absence of any program leaves people worse off," said Representative Barney Frank, the top Democrat on the House Financial Services Committee.

Even as the Obama administration argues for keeping HAMP in place, it is pressing forward on a separate track that could result in much larger aid for struggling homeowners.

Big U.S. banks are meeting with federal officials and state attorneys general at the Justice Department on Wednesday as they negotiate what could turn into a multi-billion dollar settlement over alleged abuses by the companies that collect mortgage payments.

The banks and authorities are expected to discuss a settlement proposal that the state officials sent out earlier this month, which called on banks to treat borrowers better and to reduce loan balances for some struggling homeowners.

A group of 50 state attorneys general and about a dozen federal agencies are probing bank mortgage practices that came to light last year, including the use of "robo-signers" to sign hundreds of unread foreclosure documents a day.

On March 3, state attorneys general leading the probe sent banks the outline of a proposed settlement endorsed by some federal agencies, including the Justice Department, the Housing and Urban Development Department and Treasury staff setting up the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

The banks that received the proposal and that will have representatives at Wednesday's meeting are Bank of America Corp, JPMorgan Chase & Co, Citigroup Inc, Wells Fargo & Co and Ally Financial, according to sources briefed on the meeting.

(Additional reporting by Dave Clarke; Editing by Carol Bishopric)
 

Moot

Veteran Expediter
Owner/Operator
"The absence of any program leaves people worse off," said Representative Barney Frank, the top Democrat on the House Financial Services Committee.

That is the very mindset that is dragging this country down and allowing the government to continue to grow and control more and more of our lives! Thank you Mr. Frank for being so frank.
 

layoutshooter

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
It was government "feel good" programs that were largely responsible for the economic melt down that we are going through. I say going through because I am not sure that I believe that we have seen the end of this yet. Things like the "Community Reinvestment Act" etc lead to an inflation of home prices beyond what the market could bear.

The housing market must be allowed to bottom out. Only then can it recover. Government intervention in that process will only prolong the problems.

We also have to stop the lending that the government is pushing. Like "no down payment" sub-prime home loans. That was a big part of the cause of this mess and you see zillions of adds for the exact same thing on TV all the time. The government has to shut down "Freddy and Fanny" as well. They have NO business in the mortgage business.
 

Ragman

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
The problem, as I see it, is what is going to happen next.
As stated in the article, the senete is controled by Dumb-o-crits, and king putz the 1st says he would veto anyway.
 

jpalmer

Seasoned Expediter
How exactly will it lead us worse off? What planet does that bozo live on?

The problem with the Democrats is. There far left socialist followers will not vote for them because Obama and the democrats are not liberal enough, The independents will not vote for them because they are too liberal/socialists and the majority of working Democrats are either Union members or regular working class. The Union workers will vote for them. but they are only 12% of the working class. The others won't vote at all because they are so dissatisfied with this administration.

There is really nothing they can do at this point to fix the ****e hole they created. That Piven lady is mad because she doesn't know why we are not protesting in the streets. The liberal media is in a frenzy trying to sound any bit relevant but it just isn't happening and nobody believes it anymore. George Soros is creating company after company to try and destroy the Conservative party and its media in this country. Which is only making the party and the people of this country more strong.

The Democrat party is imploding because it isn't based on truth anymore.

There won't be a Democrat back in the white house for a very long time after we are done here......Not until what they say is based in the TRUTH!
 

greg334

Veteran Expediter
Actually the problem is Congress, Conservatives and Liberals equally at fault. Both parties are at fault too, they ignored the laws and were more concern with the money for reelection.

As one of the victims of this program, in one way I hate to see it renewed but in another if the government wanted to help us with our own money, then three things should have happened;

1 - give us the $30B to fix our own problems. With only 600,000 people helped, it seems to be a waste of money but give 4 million an equal share of the money - problem solved.

2 - make sub-prime AND all adjustable rate mortgages ILLEGAL. NO MORE of them - Canada didn't have the problems we did because they didn't allow these loans to happen, a good lesson to follow.

3 - stop worrying about the banking industry and the housing industry, break up the big banks and let the housing/property prices fall to a natural level.

4 - serious finance reform, not the crap that Obama and others have had passed in the past but rather serious reform that gets rid of some of these duplicate regulations, reduce the size of the regulators and return to a sane banking system. WITH THIS there has to be a serious campaign finance reform, like when you are finished with your (re)election, the money goes into a pot for others to use - in other words no building of war chests for campaigns.
 

layoutshooter

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
Yeah, we got bit pretty bad by this stupidity. I don't see much chance of recovering from it now at my age. Not to worry, Social Security will take care of me. :mad: Sorry no good for nuthin sons of bean pickers.
 
Top