Phil, I imagine you and Diane did a lot of research before you made the investment. What club did you end up with? Thanks for this thread - it is so informative!
We chose Anytime Fitness for their many locations, private showers (most locations) and the overall attitude they presented. On their web site you will see advertised a free seven-day pass. You can try before you buy.
Discounts may be available through your health insurance company. We got that and an additional discount by paying for a full year. You will be obligated to pay monthly for a year anyway so we just paid for the full year and got the substantial discount.
We have only used one location so far but found it to be very nice, very clean and filled with modern equipment. Xiggi says he has been to other Anytime Fitness locations. Perhaps he can say more about what he has found.
Each gym is a franchise, so, much will depend on the local owner. The owner we visited with is well acquainted with the two founders of Anytime Fitness since their world headquarters remains in the same town in which they started the company and that is just a few miles away from him (Hastings, MN, near the Twin Cities).
He said the two founders could have cashed out of this very successful franchise long ago but have not done so because they continue to be interested in helping people. He spoke with other companies before settling on Anytime Fitness and opening his two gyms. He said Anytime was the only one that actually talked about helping people. The others only talked about the money.
He also talked about the requirement franchisees have to remodel their facilities every five years (new carpet, paint, etc.). Again, we have only been to one gym and it was recently remodeled and expanded. We will be interested to see what some of the other locations and older gyms look like.
Attitude was a big selling point for us. We don't need juice bars, gift shops, big swimming pools and ten thousand square feet of floor space. We need a clean, safe place to work out with private showers. The gym owner told us of a woman he signed up recently who was thrilled to realize that she would not have to buy new clothes to work out.
At the gym we visited, I was especially glad to see an old fat person using the gym. Each time we have been to the gym, there were only two or three people using it. They come and go without striking up conversations with others. It seems they are there to work out and that's about it. Very few people use the showers. Not living and working on the road like expediters do, they work out and then go home to shower.
All clubs have security in place, the owner explained. Member photos are on file and technology is in place to make sure only one person enters each time an electronic key is used. Video cameras record what goes on in the gym. The facilities are available 24 hours a day but are not staffed that long. I don't know if all gyms have them but I was surprised to see panic buttons available. They are buttons you can wear around your neck that summon the police when pushed.
It takes 30 days for your membership to populate to other locations. Our local gym owner, now aware of the disadvantage that creates for people like expediters, is talking with headquarters about getting that changed.
So far, we are pleased with our choice but we need to visit several gyms in various states to offer a final verdict.