What if? I'm talking about the morons that drive these new big cars and have the money to leave. They didn't believe it was going to happen so they stayed and didn't fuel up before the storm. Now they are sitting in lines for hours trying to do what they could have done days before. Many people interviewed said they didn't prepare because they didn't believe they would get a hurricane in ny/nj.
The Florida vacation house Diane and I have is six feet above sea level and 200 yards from the Intracostal Waterway on the East Coast. A thin barrier island separates the Atlantic Ocean from the shore, forming the waterway.
If a hurricane was predicted to hit that area, Diane and I already know we'd evacuate. But that is a very easy decision to make. We have the truck which serves as our home on the road. There is nothing in the house that we care enough about to try to protect. There is no concern that looters may invade the house in our absence. And it's a vacation house, something we can easily live without.
It's easy to say that everyone should have evacuated. They had ample warning after all. It's not like they could not see it coming. Easy to say, but not so easy to think through clearly when you are in the only home you have and all sorts of circumstances and considerations enter in.
I can't say that if I lived on Staten Island and that was my primary residence that I would have evacuated. If you have a traffic accident because you "should" have looked left when you were looking right, your reasons for looking right may have made perfect sense at the time.
Hurricane Irene recently came through and many of the people who evacuated then regretted it. It was not like they lacked experience from a recent hurricane when they reasoned their way into staying put. For some, that reasoning proved fatal for them personally or for their children or parents. For others, just up and down the way, Sandy left them mostly unscathed, so their reasoning proved correct. Their behavior was counter to the evacuation order but their reasoning proved correct.
It's not easy to say what others should do or should have done when it is almost impossible to put yourselves in their shoes and heads. It's one thing to say this and that from afar. It's something quite different to be in predicted danger and think clearly. Some evacuated, some did not and the chips fell as they did. There are as many ways to reason your way to a decision as there are people doing it.
But even if everyone stocked up their homes before the hurricane hit, and then evacuated and returned to their devastated neighborhoods with full tanks of gas, that gas lasts only so long. At some point even the fully prepared people need gas too, and many of those are standing in line today.