That's what I kinda figure also, in the 3.73 range would put me way down in the rpm range best I can figure, a search on the net does show most used diffs are in that ratio range though.The difference in the gear ratio between auto and stick is the reason you're getting both recommendations for the 3.73 and 5.86 rear end ratios. It HAS to be a stick truck he's mentioning. I'd be curious to know exactly which one so I could look up the ratios for it.