It doesn't work that way, ONESTACK. This is not a junior high school where being popular and not telling teacher is all important. We are professional, self-employed expediters who are affected positively or negatively by the professionalism or lack of it of our fellow expediters.
I have never called anyone in. I have not had to. In the very few cases where I found unprofessional behavior worthy of action, I confronted the bad actor myself. Few people are willing to do that, and they are probably smarter than me. The safer step is to call it in, which I would fully support, assuming a true bad act was there to prompt the call.
By the way, if I see a driver start his or her truck up in the morning and drive off without doing a pretrip inspection, I do not consider that a bad act. For all I know, he or she may be driving no futher than the fuel pumps and planning to go back to bed. Non-logable events do not require pretrip inspections as far as I am concerned.
I'm not out there looking for anyone to call in, but if something serious occurs and I'm there to deal with it, I will. An example is the time four trucks were at a pickup where the important freight came off a plane and was being loaded onto trucks. It was stuff bound for retail stores for a product unveiling that was to be kept under wraps until delivery. Company officials accompinied the freight by air to safeguard the product. They trusted FedEx Custom Critical to take it the final few miles.
Three teams went about their work in highly professional ways that would make any expediter proud. But then there was this B-unit solo driver also on the job. This unfortunate soul got out of his van wearing a food-stained T-shirt that was too small to cover his massive belly. Filthy sweat pants and bedroom slippers completed the ensemble. He complained loudly TO THE SHIPPER that he had to get loaded fast so he could spend some time at home (nearby) before his scheduled delivery.
I pulled him aside and told him to keep his mouth shut and hide his filthy self from the customer's view. He did not like it but complied. I also suggested that he should get out of the business as he is shaming us all. He did not like that either, and I can only hope he took my advice.
On the flip side, I recently learned of an ER-unit team driver that frequently calls drivers in for no good reason at all and is fast and loose with the facts when doing so. I guess the idea on her end is to eliminate other drivers that she sees as competiton. Her I don't worry about. Anyone that frequently calls in would be noticed as one who does so. Her reports would not carry much weight and could be easily defended against if you were questioned about it.
Regardless of who calls in or why, and it can be members of the general public too, your best defense is a good offense. And in this businss, a good offense is doing the job you were contracted to do and maintain high professional standards.
You only need one reason to do that. You do it because it is the right thing to do.