rolybil,
I see you are a new Open Forum member. Welcome! Whether you realize it or not, you have asked a very loaded question. You also ask a very good question.
The question is loaded for a few reasons:
1. Some expediters take a lot of pride in their carrier of choice, which is usually a good thing. But too much pride can interfere with one's judgement and perception of the facts. The world of sports is brimming with loyal fans who will argue with great emotion that their team is the best, even if the team's numbers put it at the bottom of the league. In sports, such loyalty is good. In expediting, it ought not be that your carrier of choice is better than all others simply because you feel loyal to them and wear their logo. Decisions about which carrier is best ought to be made on the facts that pertain to you (how much pay, how many loads, safety policies, company stability, etc.).
2. Expediters are not always fair-minded when offering opinions about carriers. It sometimes happens that an expediter changes from carrier A to carrier B because things did not work out well at carrier A. What the opinion-giving expediter may not say, or may not even realize, is that the expediter utterly failed to do the things that make other drivers successful at carrier A. Instead of examining themselves or their personal business practices, some expediters take the easier route of blaming (sometimes enthusiastically) carrier A for the expediter's errant ways.
That is not to say that a move from carrier A to carrier B is not in order. It may be exactly the right thing to do. Carriers vary greatly in regions served, trucks most used, dispatch procedures, and more. Carrier moves are wise if that's what it takes for an expediter to find the right fit. Better, though, to do good research ahead of time, so you can avoid a move later on.
3. Some expediters believe it to be in their own best interests to discourage others from coming on board with their carrier. They believe there is only so much freight to go around and any new trucks that come on board threaten to reduce their slice of the pie. Those expediters will lie to you about how bad they are doing (Ohhhh it's just terrible out there! All I do is sit!) when in fact they are doing quite well. Others who are thrilled with their current carrier will remain silent, not wanting to encourage others to come on board.
4. Some expediters, especially fleet owners, want drivers to believe that their carrier of choice is the best. They will run down other carriers or quote others who do so. Their motives are easily understood. They want drivers to consider them and their carrier, instead of other fleet owners and other carriers.
If you are researching the expediting opportunity for yourself, one of the best things you can do is find a fleet owner who is right now running trucks with multiple carriers. Interview him or her for information. Also talk to and read the posts from as many drivers as you can regarding their carrier choices. Take all driver opinions (including mine) with a grain of salt. The more driver opinions you hear and read, the better decision you can make.
Finally, don't shortchange what recruiters have to say. Recruiters often get a bad rap but they can be the best source of factual information. Don't ask a recruiter, "How well can I do at your company?" and then hear only what you want to hear.
Instead, ask questions that can be answered with factual information like "How many trucks in your fleet now compared to last year? How much gross income did your average D-unit produce in 2005? What is your company's turnover ratio? and What provisions in your contract can you show me that distinguish your company from the others?"
Now...about FedEx Custom Critical, my carrier of choice; Diane and I run team with them because after doing thorough industry research and talking face-to-face with numerous other carriers, we found FedEx to be the best fit for us. At FedEx, and in a reefer-eqipped straight truck, which is our truck of choice, we can earn more income than we can with any other carrier out there (Landstar being a possible exception). FedEx's national reach also enables us to see the country, which was one of our reasons for entering the business.
We also like it that FedEx is a large corporate entity and not a smaller carrier that tries to be friendly and like family to its drivers. We already have friends and family. Our carrier choice is a business decision, not a social one. FedEx runs a highly professional operation. We make our reputation there by the numbers we produce, and not by the friends we have "inside."