You are confusing peoples' opinion on this "challenge" with how they feel about ALS. I don't need to ask Grace Berry, Jack was a friend - I know what ALS does, and how cruel it is.
And I think the idea of challenging people to either donate $100 or dump a bucket of ice water over their heads is likely to raise as much resistance as awareness. Most people will not enjoy being told how much to donate, for starters, and the "challenge" is just bewildering. Maybe if anyone explained that it's meant to mimic the effect of ALS [if only briefly], it would make sense - but I've seen a dozen such "challenges" posted, and no one said anything beyond "pay up, or get soaked". As was mentioned, that just sounds like extortion.
Giving to a worthy cause is something we should do because it's the right thing to do, not because it's the less unpleasant choice.
Cheri,
There is nothing in my comment that states about people being told how much money to donate!!!!! You give what you can afford to give!
My point is that some people are saying this is silly. But it's not. It's a way to raise awareness and raise money to find research to find a cure.
Think about this! When Avon does their breast cancer 4 day walk, you must pay to sign up to walk. Is that not extortion? When comedian/actor Jerry Lewis does his MS telethons and parades all the stars and the young children in wheel chairs across the stage on national television in hopes of getting donations making you feel sad and sorry, is that not extortion? Well actually that is exploitation!
But my point is made! And if you understand the challenge some people do the bucket thing and don't pay. Others do the bucket and also pay!
No disrespect to Jack Berry (RIP) or his memory he was my friend too! But anybody who has a loved one who's been inflicted with this disease knows the pain and suffering. But you being a former nurse should know its a cruel disease!
My original comment so please go back and re-read it, is simply stating to someone who commented, it being silly and dumb, is that it is not!