The key really is that you have to be unmarked.
NYC DOT - Truck or Commercial Vehicle?
Unmarked AND regular tags, not commercial
Sent from my XT1635-01 using
EO Forums mobile app
No, it's both (in order to get a ticket). The quoted text makes that very clear.
Other states have different criteria for what does and does not require commercial tags, and NY doesn't impose its criteria for that onto other states, so having commercial tags from out of state, in and of itself, means very little. You can be marked and permanently altered (for property carrying), but if you don't also have commercial plates they won't consider you to be a commercial vehicle. You can have commercial plates and be permanently altered, but if you aren't marked then you likewise aren't a commercial vehicle in NY state.
I got intensely schooled on that particular law after receiving a ticket for "CMV on Parkway" and having to pay the fine (which is not cheap).
After having lived in Jersey (Howell Township and Manasquan) for a while and making many trips to JFK, well, the Belt Parkway is just how you go right? When I started expediting it never really occurred to me that the Belt Parkway was an actual
parkway parkway that I shouldn't be driving on, because, I mean, that's how you go to JFK! In my mind Belt Parkway was just the name of the road and "parkway" didn't have any special meaning, could have been Belt Boulevard or Belt Road for all I cared. And, I had gone to and from JFK several times expediting while marked, permanently altered and commercial plated without incident. Luck ran out, and then I discovered that they're serious about that Parkway and "passenger cars only" crap.