My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely not.

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
My week started at 08:03 Friday morning. I joined an experienced dispatcher at her station and began to observe. Dispatchers have around 50 loads underway to monitor and keep tabs on. They have around another 50 loads waiting to be dispatched. Many of those 50 have to have a driver on scene at the shipper within 2 hours. Some of the 50 underway have problems. They are late due to weather, breakdown etc. and that all has to be dealt with. They have drivers on their team calling in for various issues that have to be dealt with. They have calls rolling over from various other systems that they have to answer and resolve if possible. If they can’t resolve it they have to get it to someone who can. That’s what they start the day with. More are added as the day goes on.

While all this is going on the CSR’s are in their area across the room booking more loads that will go to the various dispatchers, further increasing the number of things they have to keep track of. The CSR I sat with has 2 computer screens. One is not enough to keep track of all the email quote requests as well as using the system to quote and book telephone inquiries. When the load is booked, the CSR will check for available trucks. If there is a truck available the load will be offered. With 2 screens of loads to deal with there is no time for anything except sending it to a truck if one’s available. If there isn’t a truck available it will go to the dispatcher to be added to their list of action items since as we’ve seen they have nothing to do all day anyway.

People frequently post on here about the favoritism in dispatch. They post about how they are being discriminated against. They post about how they are always chosen for the crappy loads, the short runs, whatever is negative. That couldn’t be further from the truth. They don’t have time to play favorites. They don’t have time to search out driver X to offer the crappy load. They literally spend from 1 to 2 seconds per screen, grabbing the first available truck and sending the load offer out. At that rate they can get to each of the 100-120 loads they are dealing with once every 2 or 3 minutes. That doesn’t really give time for all this favoritism and retaliation people accuse them of. Oh, did I mention that in addition to all the rest they’ve also got a half dozen or more items that are blinking on the screen? Those are the ones with the biggest problems that are currently on track for a service failure and need more time and attention.

My week in dispatch ended at 13:47 Friday when I was the only truck within 100 miles for a pickup in 73 minutes about 24 miles down the road from the office. I took the run and was glad my week in dispatch was over. They aren’t perfect and I’ll complain about them when it’s deserved. I won’t make accusations when I don’t know what I’m talking about. Anyone who thinks they have the time or interest or inclination to spend time working around trucks or being mean to certain trucks hasn’t spent time with them and doesn’t know what they are talking about. They just don’t have the time.

Leo Bricker, 73's K5LDB, OOIDA Life Member 677319
Owner, Panther trucks 5508, 5509, 5641
Highway Watch Participant, Truckerbuddy
EO Forum Moderator
----------
Support the entire Constitution, not just the parts you like.
 

Bruno

Veteran Expediter
Fleet Owner
US Marines
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

GREAT POST !!! Leo

I have to agree with you 100% I have sat at the home office with FedEx dispatcher's and they can't even dispatch a single driver on a 530 miles load if they are more than 20 miles away. Because of the 550 mile rule. If the load is 530 miles and the driver is 22 miles away they will not get to take that load all the way unless they get the okay from the higher ups at the home office.

My wife which is a former dispatcher at Panther said the same thing Leo said. They didn't have time to look up who's truck it is or to find a certain driver to cover a load. She just wanted to get the load covered and move on to the next load. No matter if it FedEx, Panther, Tri-state, Landstar ot TST, they don't have time to play FAVORITISM.
 

jaminjim

Veteran Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Thanks for the post Leo. But why in the world would you spend an entire week there?
 

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

The week I spent there was last Friday from 08:03 to 13:47. I called it a week based on the work load and the very fast pace and the pressure level. I wanted another way to get the point across that it isn't game time and they don't have the time or interest in screwing certain drivers.

Leo Bricker, 73's K5LDB, OOIDA Life Member 677319
Owner, Panther trucks 5508, 5509, 5641
Highway Watch Participant, Truckerbuddy
EO Forum Moderator
----------
Support the entire Constitution, not just the parts you like.
 

Rollo

Seasoned Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

>GREAT POST !!! Leo
>
>I have to agree with you 100% I have sat at the home office
>with FedEx dispatcher's and they can't even dispatch a
>single driver on a 530 miles load if they are more than 20
>miles away. Because of the 550 mile rule. If the load is 530
>miles and the driver is 22 miles away they will not get to
>take that load all the way unless they get the okay from the
>higher ups at the home office.
>

Good positive thoughts! I am sure that if anything they hate to get turned down and that may be the only descrimination that is biasing their choice to offer a load. What I am interested in knowing is the 550 rule or how many dispatchers are required to follow it. I have only been in this business a little over three years and mostly with small operations. I have not heard of such a rule. Maybe if it were followed in my case, I would not be having to turn down so many loads. Last two weeks in over 4,000 loaded miles, I have have been given 500, 800, 760, 360, 1180 and 780 offers (often without 5-6 hours between). After shutting down for three days under complete and total exhaustion, I am still not ready to put myself into service today.

It hasn't always been this way and I am solo o/o with nothing more than a one ton extended cargo van. If I am going to stay in this business, it will have to be with a company that dispatches with safety in mind. Any thoughts for me?
 

ihamner

Expert Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Thanks so much for sharing this with us. The dispatch area is totally unknown to us. Every bit of information that explains what the dispatchers are going through helps us as we deal with them. Our dispatchers have been great with us and very patient during our learning process.

India Hamner
FedEx CC
D Unit
Life is short.
Stay awake for it!
 

redytrk

Veteran Expediter
Charter Member
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

> I have only been in this business a little over three years and mostly with small operations. I have not heard of such a rule. Maybe if it were followed in my case, I would not be having to turn down

The so called 550 rule is what the companies use to determine the amount of miles a SOLO driver can leaglly drive before he/she must take 10 hrs off.
 

Turtle

Administrator
Staff member
Retired Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Ooooh. That hits a nerve. First and foremost, accept loads with your own safety in mind. Nothing else matters, especially the opinion of someone in "Safety" or a dispatcher.

Most dispatchers don't have the time to check and see what you have been running or if you have had enough sleep. If you are in-service then you are in-service. They are looking to cover loads, and if you're available and your number comes up, you get the call, even if you just ot off an 800 mile run a few minutes ago. But you cannot just take load after load if it compromises your safety.

And you certainly cannot rely on the "Safety" department to keep you safe, either (speaking primarily of solo and van drivers, here). The Safety department has a different agenda than you do when it comes to your safety. They won't admit it often, but it's true.

To wit:

Had a load from Canada to St Louis that amounted to a 12 hour day, with delays at loading and the delay in getting the load cleared through Customs. It was about 600 miles. 10 Minutes after I had dropped it off I got a load offer of 200 miles deadhead for 900 loaded. That's a long haul right on top of a 12 hour day, so I had to take a close look at the run, where it was going, the routing, what time of day I'd be here or there, and make sure I would be able to get enough sleep along the way to keep it safe and still get it there on-time.

Some people can take a 15 minute power nap and be fine. Not me, I need 90 minutes, and depending on how tire I am, up to three hours for my power nap. But if I go much more than 3 hours, instead of waking up refreshed, I wake up tired and sleepy because my body wants its full 8 hours. With that in mind, it wasn't hard to plan the trip and account for sleep periods and to make sure they could be timed to avoid traffic or other problems that lie in waiting.

The run was from a little east of KC to south of Birmingham. So, the plan was to deadhead the 200 miles and make the pickup, then drive a couple more hours and then take a break from 2-3 hours, then head back out, getting through St Louis in the middle of the night, and more importantly, hitting Nashville before 6AM, which would allow me to scoot through there in 10 or 15 minutes, and then grab another nap somewhere around the AL state line. Then I would be alert and ready to handle the Interstate traffic through downtown Birmingham at noon, and with more than enough time to deliver the load early.

Pulled off to take my first break, and I get a message from "Safety" that my break must me a solid 5 hours. Period. That edict wasn't for my benefit, it was for Safety's benefit, to make sure they could show that I took a 5 hour break that would cover their behinds if I got into a wreck. My safety wasn't an issue with them, because that would still leave me with a solid 10 hours of driving, which is flat out too much with too little rest coming off the amount of driving I had already done.

The result was, I woke up tired, and still had a long way to go. I hit Nashville at the predicted 8AM, the worst possible time, and it caused a 90 minute delay in getting through town. Certainly no time left for an additional nap on the other end, either, as the forced break already assured that the load was going to be at least one hour late.

And to top it off, at the end of a lot of driving, when I'm at my most tired, I have to hit noon traffic in Birmingham. I had no business driving at that point. None.

And that's the last time I allow someone to try and drive my van for me from a cushy chair in another city. That's what Donald Rumsfeld was fired for. You can't fight a war from Washington anymore than you can drive a van from an office. No one knows you and your body, and how it reacts to certain situations, better than you do. If you're logging and doing HOS rules, it's not a problem to make sure you have enough rest. But in a van you have to do it yourself, be practical, not stoopid (not saying you are, but a lot of them out there are just morons).

The other day I had a 1400 mile run from California to Kansas, with no breaks built in, so I had to build my own. Which was pretty easy considering the 70 and 75 MPH speed limits for most of the way. But, the same thing happened with Safety. Safety wanted me to take a 5 hour break, and they wanted me to take it when they wanted, instead of when it would actually benefit me. They were more interested in my showing a solid 5 hour break than they were in my actual safety. I ignored them and instead took 3 separate breaks totaling more than 8 hours, and as a result I was refreshed and alert for the entire trip, and was on-time.

Most companies that dispatch with safety in mind, dispatch with Safety in mind, as in the Safety Department and compliance, not necessarily the safety of the driver. One way is the 550 rule (which is a rule or policy of a specific company, and not a federal rule or anything) or with other companies it's a different mileage figure. Other methods is to Pony Express it with 2 or more drivers, have one driver take it half way and offload the freight to another for the rest of the trip. But sometimes that second vehicle isn't available, so you have to take it the entire way. And that's where you have to show restraint on accepting a long load unless you can ensure that it can be done safely.

When I accept a run I am stating that I can make the run safely and on time. You must have both, as one without the other is meaningless. On-time but unsafe is a disaster waiting to happen, and safely but late just won't work. If I get a load offer that I can't do both for, I turn it down. Simple as that. Unless it's a kidney or a beating heart inside a Coleman cooler or something, I can't think of a single load that's worth jeopardizing my safety over.
 

pelicn

Veteran Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Excellent post! Many times when we don't get an immediate answer to a question, we forget that we are just one of the hundreds of questions that are being asked at the same time. Thank you for spending the "week" and reporting your findings. :)
 

Dog_House2691

Seasoned Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Favortism? Well they must call it something else now at Panther,because it just happened to me.I arrived in Knoxville,TN. on Saturday morning 12/09/06 and was 2nd out and Monday 12/11/06 at 12:00 I was first out.Another cargo van driver and I were sitting in the tv room at the Flying J and he was 2nd out and just recieved a Load out to Davenport,IA. 800 miles.Called imediately to my team and they of course said they did'nt know what happened.Leo maybe the dipatchers are so quick of hand it was'nt noticed,this new driver council really needs to look further into this matter.As they say time is MONEY....Play by the RULES or dont play at all.
 

Bugsy Siegel

Seasoned Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Hmmm, with all those loads, I have to wonder why, when I drove t/t, I was always waiting for a load that when it came in - it was already 8-10 hours old!

Different world there I guess, wasn't expedited freight, it was "get it here when it gets here" freight! :)
 

davekc

Senior Moderator
Staff member
Fleet Owner
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

I think it would be of great benefit for drivers that feel there is this favoritism or whatever, to pay dispatch a visit, and see exactly how they operate. I really think it would eliminate alot of misconceptions. Probably an idea for alot of companies where these issues come up. We have been with several carriers over the years and this was an issue with every one of them.







Davekc
owner
22 years
PantherII
EO moderator
 

Dog_House2691

Seasoned Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Dave,it might not be called favoritism but since it just happened to me today they should look into ways of preventing it.
 

davekc

Senior Moderator
Staff member
Fleet Owner
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

It could very well have been a human error on their part. Anything is possible, but I don't believe it is a regular occurance based on what we have seen there. We had pretty much the same observations that Leo had when we visited. Alot of different items go into truck selection so it is hard to tell without having all the information.






Davekc
owner
22 years
PantherII
EO moderator
 

davekc

Senior Moderator
Staff member
Fleet Owner
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

I didn't mean that so much unless there is a difference in your carrying capacity in some way.
Not all vans of the same make have the same dimensions.
Outside of that, other issues are distance to shipper, did the other truck have a first out, were they on hometime, or did they have better acceptance or on time percentages?
If all that is equal, then its dispatch error.








Davekc
owner
22 years
PantherII
EO moderator
 

Dog_House2691

Seasoned Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

Dave,same size van.My acceptance is 78% in service 80% safety and on time 100%
 

LDB

Veteran Expediter
Retired Expediter
RE: My week in dispatch. Favoritism? Definitely no

I'm sorry you were passed over on a job. I don't know what happened but I can tell you they are too busy to have time for any favoritism. The other driver may have had a first out for some reason. They may have misread something on the screen. It could have been something we can't even come up with in supposition. Whatever the case I'd bet on human error or a specific reason but not favoritism by that or any other name. They just don't have the time.

Leo Bricker, 73's K5LDB, OOIDA Life Member 677319
Owner, Panther trucks 5508, 5509, 5641
Highway Watch Participant, Truckerbuddy
EO Forum Moderator
----------
Support the entire Constitution, not just the parts you like.
 
Top