I had to change something.
Hi Hawk
Now that you heard from all the others I will throw in my 2cents.
I would suggest for you to get the Verizon. And I rate them a +10 WHY??? See I know where you live and about how far a delivery range you have. I also have had Nextel, I give them a -2, they are bad for places anywhere out side of the Cleveland area. AT&T, I give them a +9 only because you can get a better rate from Verizon. Sprint, +4, just as JJ said you will drop a lot of calls. Altell, -5, They are real bad.
With the Verizon in your area the coverage area is all of Ohio and part of PA,& Mich. For a total of $39.95 a month you can get 400 anytime minuets and 1000phone to phone minuets, with unlimited nights and weekends, and no roam, along with voice and text messaging. You can get email and the Internet also for $5.00 more a month, and with the second phone you can share minuets. The service is great, the only place I have a dead area is coming up Rt14 out of Salem, and it is for about 8miles. They will give you a $200 phone for $50 with a second one free. Go Check them out.